This week · as of Wed Nov 4

6-2, on track for 8-4 in the regular season.

Now

Career arc

Stature score reached, by season of his head-coaching careerFBS medianSMUTCUTCURiceRicePower Programperennial contenderNational Programrespectable, streakyRegional Programthe building-block levelSMU when he took over: 26.6 (Regional Program I), its final 2021 readingtook overSMU, 2022: 7-6, National Program IIISMU, 2022: 7-6, National Program III20227-6SMU, 2023: 11-3, National Program II202311-3SMU, 2024: 11-3, National Program I202411-3SMU, 2025: 9-4, National Program I20259-4SMU, 2026: 6-2, National Program ISMU, 2026: 6-2, National Program I20266-2+13.8best: 2025gray dashed: rival programs · ○ the program when he took over · Dashed segments are program changes — spacing is not proportional to calendar time

Bowls and playoffs: 1-3

2022New Mexico BowlL 23-242023Fenway BowlL 14-232024CFP first roundL 10-382025Holiday BowlW 24-19

This week Wed Nov 4

  • Last gameL 27-30 at Syracuse Sat Oct 31
  • This season6-2
  • On track for8-4 regular season
  • Nextvs. Virginia Tech Fri Nov 6
  • Stature34th of 138 FBS programs

What the result changed

  • AP poll #19 → unranked out of the poll
  • Playoff odds 22% → 12% CFB Zeitgeist forecast, before and after

Friday: vs. Virginia Tech

Fri Nov 6, 7 pm ET ESPN · Virginia Tech is 6-2 · Lashlee vs. James Franklin: 0-1 · SMU’s chance to win: 70% (the site’s model)

His week

Several stories this week →

The headlines, Nov 1–4 from a few outlets

Fans are frustrated with SMU

That’s my chief complaint with Lashlee - what you have is what you got. No real improvement throughout the year from game to game.

Our defense is so unbelievably bad Jesus.  At least fraud watch is over, we’re 100% confirmed now.

It’s infuriating! It’s either not being coached or he’s not learning. Thought he’d made a step up after the decision making last week wrt throwing it away more

Fan mood · last 3 weeks · more negative than 3 in 4 FBS fan bases

Offense: 27th of 138 per play. Defense: 75th.

Offense, per play27thOffense, starting field position18thDefense, per play75thDefense, opponents' starting field position16thWorstBest
Offense, per play27th of 138Offense, starting field position18th of 138Defense, per play75th of 138Defense, opponents' starting field position16th of 138WorstBest
Through 8 games. Each tick is an FBS team, adjusted for opponent strength (CFB Zeitgeist model); the dot is SMU. The other two rows are where SMU stands furthest from the middle. Early-season numbers move a lot.

4 games left

  1. Fri Nov 6vs. Virginia Tech (6-2)ESPN70%
  2. Sat Nov 14vs. Wake Forest (7-1)34%
  3. Sat Nov 21at Notre Dame (7-1)NBC13%
  4. Sat Nov 28at Stanford (4-5)90%

Percent: SMU’s chance to win, from the site’s model. Records are through today. Networks as announced; the rest are set closer to kickoff.

How the season got here

Where SMU stood among 138 FBS programs by stature after each game (1st is the highest; the CFB Zeitgeist ledger).

28th34th40thPreseason34thFlorida State W 27-24Florida State W 27-24W 27-24Florida State33rdUC Davis W 56-10UC Davis W 56-10W 56-10UC Davis33rdLouisville L 31-41Louisville L 31-41L 31-41Louisville33rdMissouri State W 34-24Missouri State W 34-24W 34-24Missouri State33rdBoston College W 25-16Boston College W 25-16W 25-16Boston College33rdVirginia W 23-13Virginia W 23-13W 23-13Virginia34thCalifornia W 59-20California W 59-20W 59-20California33rdSyracuse L 27-30Syracuse L 27-30L 27-30Syracuse33rd
  1. Oct 26–Nov 1L 27-30 at Syracuse6 headlines · 62nd of 138SMU's Rhett Lashlee Ready For Overdue Road Test vs. Syracuse Yahoo Sports
  2. Oct 19–25W 59-20 vs. California7 headlines · 53rd of 138Rhett Lashlee Is Making It Impossible For College Football To Ignore SMU Yahoo Sports
  3. Oct 12–18W 23-13 vs. Virginia4 headlines · 55th of 138Rhett Lashlee is happy to ride with Kevin Jennings, building up SMU's star QB On3
  4. Oct 5–11No game4 headlines · 59th of 138SMU's Rhett Lashlee Praises Mustangs' Gameplan In Boston College Win Yahoo Sports
  5. Sep 28–Oct 4W 25-16 vs. Boston College9 headlines · 48th of 138SMU gaining traction with blue-chip recruits, excitement growing around Rhett Lashlee, the Mustangs On3
  6. Sep 21–27 · rebuiltW 34-24 vs. Missouri State4 headlines · 66th of 138Rhett Lashlee 'Confident' In SMU Turnaround vs. Missouri State Yahoo Sports

Each week as this page showed it at the time. Weeks marked rebuilt came before this page existed: they were built afterward from only what was known by the end of that week.

Watch the biggest plays from SMU’s games, ranked by how much each moved the chance to win.

Report card

Above the median on both sides of the ball — 72nd percentile offense, 60th percentile defense.

SMU, every completed season graded against the whole field, then averaged.

Offense

B+
of which —72nd
efficiency — 72nd percentile success rate, 2022–25
B66th
Standard-downs success
B+78th
Passing-downs success
B62nd
Trench push (line yards)
B+76th
Red-zone scoring rate
B68th
Power-success (short yardage)
C40th
Ball security (giveaways per game)

Defense

B
of which —60th
60th percentile SP+ defense, 2022–25
A81st
Front-7 havoc
A82nd
Secondary havoc
B-57th
Stuff rate (run defense)
B-56th
Takeaways per game

Each season is his team’s percentile among every team with that stat (the share it beat), averaged over his completed seasons here; a mid-season takeover year and the season in progress aren’t graded. Letters: A+ 90th percentile and up, A 80, B+ 70, B 60, B− 50, C+ 45, C 40, C− 30, D 15, F below.

Poach watch

This winter

11%chance he leaves this winter for a head-coaching job elsewhere, or an NFL coordinator jobNoticed16th-highest of 132 FBS head coaches
0%50%+

Our poach model, on his record so far, the win chances for every game he has left, his program, his pay and his background. Ranked against the 132 FBS head coaches this season. The zone words describe the market’s interest; none of them says he is leaving.

What drives his number

The biggest factors in his profile, each against the typical FBS head coach today. The games he has left are priced into the number, not listed here.

  • ▲ Higher
    Age 43 · neither at his alma mater nor in the state he was born in
  • ▲ Higher
    His team is 6-2, outscoring opponents by 13.0 points a game · AP-ranked
  • ▲ Higher
    His 5th season at SMU
How good is this number? It ranks a head coach who leaves for another head-coaching job ahead of one who stays 78 to 82% of the time, and its average came within a point of the share who actually left. What it can’t do

Tested on every FBS head coach from 2012 through 2025, each season scored by a model fit only on the seasons before it. From three games on, given one coach who left for a head-coaching job elsewhere or an NFL coordinator job and one who stayed, it ranked the one who left ahead 79 to 82% of the time; in a season’s first two games, 78%. Its average chance came within a point of the share who actually left. It counts a move a coach makes while he still holds the job; when his school ends it, that doesn’t count, even if another school then hires him.

  • The live number prices the games he has left with the power model’s ratings from this season. The test priced them with each team’s rating from the season before, because ratings made during past seasons were not kept, so this live version could not be replayed.
  • Programs new to FBS have no FBS record before this season in the data it reads, so their coaches are scored without one.
  • It is frozen: it learns nothing from 2026 until a deliberate refit.
  • A coach hired in December needs his background (age, alma mater, the state he was born in) added before his first game, or he shows as not rated.