#44

Mitch McCarthy

Senior punter for Indiana. 2025: 41.6 yards per punt, 37 punts.

P · Indiana · Sr. · #44

6′5″ · 230 lb · Melbourne, VIC

Returning to Indiana for 2026

The numbers

41.6

yards per punt · 2025

37 punts · long of 55 · 15 inside the 20

Best game: 5 punts, 48.2 avg, vs Miami

The story

4 punter for Indiana. 2025: 41.6 yards per punt, 37 punts.

  • Signed with UCF in 2022.
  • Transferred from UCF to Indiana in 2025.
His career, year by year

How he plays

Drops it inside the 20 and pins them on their own goal line.

The full scouting read

Mitch McCarthy

P · Indiana · Sr · #44

Drops it inside the 20 and pins them on their own goal line. Two head coaches in four seasons, at two different programs. The receipt: 1 tackles against UCLA — Week 9, 2025.

Low coverage — composed from the verified record.

  • positional archetype classification
  • head-coach lineage
  • game log
Stats from CFBD · ESPN · fan discourse. Every figure computed from source tables — not invented. Methodology